Wednesday, November 18, 2026

EMRS: Tasmanian Labor Takes The Lead!

EMRS Lib 24 (-2) ALP 25 (+2) ON 23 (+2) Grn 14 (-2) IND 13 (-1) Others 1 (-)

Seat estimate Lib 9 ALP 9 ON 8 Grn 4 IND 4 + 1 undecided Lib/ALP/Grn

The last EMRS poll for 2026 is out and this one is quite interesting.  Santa was a socialist all along and he's given the red team a modest but nice little present.  Although all the movements from the August sample are within the margin of error the poll sees Labor back in the primary vote lead for the first time since last May.  The May 2025 poll was the last before Labor's fateful decision to bring on a vote of no confidence against the Rockliff government, which led to the July election at which the opposition fared badly.  But while 25 isn't the mythical 30, it's the party's best vote since One Nation appeared on the scene, and is actually about what they were getting before One Nation arrived.  Seen from the perspective of the damage One Nation is doing to Labor's primary in Victoria and federally, this is actually quite good and Labor can go to the break with some kind of optimism.

For the Liberals, on the other hand, 24% can't be considered good.  They are continuing to bleed support to apparently One Nation despite said party scarcely existing as a state campaigning unit (Lee Hanson is an intending Senator and there are no candidates for state elections yet). This poll will at the very best do nothing to stop the current trickle of media speculation that Premier Jeremy Rockliff could be moving on in 2027. This said, there has been speculation that Rockliff could depart soon on and off for many years, including well before he became Premier.  

In the leadership stakes, nobody seems on the nose this time; indeed all three leaders are up, with Rockliff on net -1 (up 6), Willie on net -6 (up 8) and Rosalie Woodruff also net -6 (up 10).  Both Rockliff and Willie are also, oddly, up as preferred Premier with Rockliff leading 41-33.  Preferred leader scores tend to favour incumbents.  So there are plenty of voters out there who remain well disposed to Rockliff, but wouldn't currently vote 1 for his government.

The poll also sees health continue to jockey with cost of living as the most nominated state issues.  Unlike many pollsters who ask respondents to choose from a set of issues, EMRS asks respondents to write their key issue, and then summarises the responses.  I think this is quite a good approach for spotting emerging issues.  

We are approaching a crunch point in debate about Macquarie Point stadium costings, where it will be clear the unpopular stadium is going to cost more in presumably public money than Premier Rockliff said at the time it was approved, which was in turn much more than he said at the election.  The government may also have lost some bark, or at least deserves to, after a silly outbreak of Christmas culture warring over festivities at a school.  The comments seem to have had a bad effect on the school concerned, not surprisingly since it seems they were substantively not true, and the Premier has apologised, sort-of.

Seats

At this stage I am not rolling out a new vote share model table because I want to give it some panelbeating to better redistribute the One Nation rise from the high teens into the 20s, and the Victorian election is more urgent.  However there's a pretty clear pattern in modelling for these sorts of vote shares depending on who does what at the election.  

These comments assume the new boundaries are in place.  I note that although the new boundaries will be in place for the next federal election, it still takes some time for them to be passed through state parliament.

In Bass, Braddon and Lyons on current numbers the majors would win two each and One Nation would win two.  One Nation might lead on primaries in Braddon but even if they get over 2.5 quotas (31.3%) my model does not find any seat for them.  The final seat would be won by the Greens in Lyons and Bass (remember this is just a model output; if George Razay triples his vote the model has no way to anticipate that, but it seems unlikely) and by Craig Garland in Braddon.

Franklin on its new boundaries would be two Liberals, two Labor, one Green, one One Nation and an independent who I'll assume to be David O'Byrne.  Clark would be one Liberal, one Labor, one Green, one One Nation and notionally two independents, plus one unclear seat.  I'm assuming the two indies to be Kristie Johnston and Peter George (or substitute in a case where he's retired; the campaigning movement that elected George has gone on to other successes and could well find a suitable replacement.) As noted before Johnston would have a tough choice between neo-Lyons (which contains Glenorchy of which she was Mayor) and neo-Clark, but in 2025 she got more votes in neo-Clark, and would not be losing any real number of those to One Nation.  

The final Clark seat would be between the Liberals, Labor and Greens, who would all start on pretty similar totals.  The Greens would need to spread their vote between two candidates to be competitive, and with Helen Burnet having left their most obvious path to do so is the somewhat risky but ambitious strategy of running both Vica Bayley and Rosalie Woodruff in Clark and finding a new lead candidate in Franklin.  

One might imagine in this scenario that the post-count saw prolonged suspense over whether the Liberals could win a tenth seat and a combined majority with One Nation, or whether there would be a combined majority of Labor, Greens and left independents, with the Liberals no longer the largest party.  In any cases current primary vote shares would make it very difficult for any party to supply the ministry by itself and multiple-party Cabinets or including independents from the Legislative Council as ministers would be necessary.

It's notable that the distribution of One Nation's vote means it can be a par with the majors but struggling to win more than eight seats, because the new Clark and Franklin are both bad for it.

DemosAU Poll from September

I was in Samarkand in September and didn't have time then to cover off on the state's other regular pollster, DemosAU, who released a poll in September.  This poll still had the Liberals well ahead on 28% of Labor then on 22% and One Nation on 21% with the Greens on 15% and independents on 10%.  It was very little changed from the previous DemosAU.  As the Liberals were also well ahead in the previous DemosAU there is something of a divide between the two poll series regarding how far backwards they have gone since the state election.  It's notable that DemosAU names the leader as part of the voting intention question, but only for the major parties.  (I'm not super keen on this approach but I guess it reduces the risk of the respondent mixing up state and federal politics.)  On these numbers the Liberals would be the largest party and there would most likely be a slim Liberal/One Nation combined majority, probably the same 10-9-8-4-4 scenario as the previous poll.  So not much difference between the two most recent polls on the seat distribution front.



No comments:

Post a Comment

The comment system is unreliable. If you cannot submit comments at all you can email me a comment (via email link in profile) - email must be entitled: Comment for publication, followed by the name of the article you wish to comment on. Comments are accepted in full or not at all. Emailed comments will be published under the name the email is sent from unless an alias is clearly requested and stated. If you submit a comment which is not accepted within a few days you can also email me and I will check if it has been received (sometimes I do not see notifications for an incoming comment). Comments never appear immediately as I have to manually approve comments prior to publication.