This article is an assessment of lower house seats in the Victorian election that are either being considered winnable for the Greens or are being talked about as interesting concerning them. For upper house regions see here. The intention of this article isn't to try to predict a result in every seat but to highlight some factors that could be relevant in modelling these seats.
The Greens are currently polling well for the Victorian election and could be headed for their highest vote in a mainland state election ever. At the same time the Labor vote is collapsing. The Greens nationwide have a long history of overhyping how many seats they will win at elections. Some independent models however have suggested they could win as many as eight or nine (or even off one poll ten!) lower house seats in this one - is this at all realistic? I should note first that anyone who was modelling this before last week was jumping the gun to a degree, because the Greens' prospects in some of these seats are significantly dependent on how to vote card decisions by other parties. These came out in the last week and some were surprising, especially the Liberals registering open how to vote cards in Brunswick and Footscray, in both of which they claim the Labor candidates are too pro-Palestinian. Less surprisingly Labor registered open how to vote cards in Prahran and Caulfield, where preferencing the Greens is considered to be sensitive for Jewish Labor voters (this follows them doing so in overlapping Macnamara at the federal election).
My rule for including a seat in this list for now is that either (i) the main betting agency or Australian Election Forecasts (not a betting agency!) has given the Greens an implied 10% or greater chance of winning the seat at some recent time, or (ii) there has been modelling talk about the seat in the Tally Room Discord or in other informed places and I have thought the seat was worth discussing. More seats may be added. Inclusion of a seat does not of itself mean, and is not to be reported as me saying, that the Greens can or will win the seat.
Overall there is a general expectation that the Greens will hold Brunswick, Melbourne and probably Richmond. Of the other six seats that are serious targets, I think a lot of them are more arguable either way than the current betting odds (which have the Greens favourites in Northcote and Prahran but not the rest) suggest.
General Considerations
These are some general things to think about in modelling these seats.
Firstly, the overall state picture following the polling rise of One Nation and the collapse in Labor support is of a roughly 14.5% swing against Labor since the last election, a swing around 3.5% against the Coalition, a swing around 3% to the Greens and One Nation getting around 22% more or less from scratch. But when One Nation's vote surges, it does not surge in a linear fashion, and in many of the inner-city seats the party will poll half or less of whatever it gets statewide. This means that all else being equal (ignoring factors like local independents and minor party runs) the swing against Labor will be lower and there may well be small primary vote swings to the Liberals. But what One Nation does get will still flow pretty strongly to the Liberals and so the Liberals may still get 3CP swings to them of several points.
However inner city seats can also move to their own drum. In the 2024 Queensland election, Labor suffered a large swing and the loss of many seats, but was able to hold its vote reasonably well in the inner city. I am not so sure we will see that widely at this election as neither Ben Carroll nor Labor's policies seem particularly inner-city focused. But we may see it in some seats.
As for the Greens, high polling for this party always inspires a degree of caution, but in recent elections they haven't particularly overperformed. At state and federal general elections since 2022, on average the Greens have underperformed their final polling average by 0.56%. With Labor's vote in freefall and having replaced a female left leader with a Labor Right guy, a surge in Greens support makes intuitive sense - but the Greens don't always gain votes when they should. There has been a tendency for Greens support to spread out (noticeable in the federal election) as their supporters get priced out of inner urban real estate so there is the possibility that if the surge is real it is going to land in what were their second-tier targets at the federal election. This is another reason why some of those seats are getting big attention despite the adverse Liberal preferencing decisions.
Liberal Preferences
Liberal Party how to vote card choices matter where the Liberals are excluded because Liberal Party voters are among the highest how to vote card followers. In 2022 two Greens target seats, Preston and Northcote were data-entered. In these 29.4% and 28.3% of Liberal voters copied the how to vote card. This rose to over 50% in some seats where the Liberals were competitive. At that election, with the Liberals preferencing the Greens, Liberal preferences flowed 72.3% to the Greens in Preston (which was vacant) and 64.8% in Northcote. The 3CP flows from the Liberal exclusion (these include votes reaching the Liberals from other sources) were 4.9% and 4.0% lower respectively. In Brunswick, Melbourne and Northcote the Greens received Liberal HTV preferences in 2022 having not done so in 2018 and their share of the Liberal 3CP flows were 22.3 points, 22.5 points and 24.8 points higher in that order. These differences were worth 2.9%, 4.7% and 3.9% on the two-candidate preferred. In Northcote, assuming that the voters who copied the Liberal how to vote card would have done so had it flowed the other way rather closely matches this figure (3.5%). On this basis, being now preferenced against isn't death for the Greens' chances in seats where they are getting a large implied 2CP swing from Labor just because Labor's primary is going down when theirs isn't, but it does make things harder in seats where the Greens start behind and some of the implied swing is soaked on just bringing the margin to zero. Life is easier for the Greens where Labor is knocked into third.
But changes in Liberal how to vote cards aren't the only thing at play here. In 2025, in federal seats in Victoria the flow from Liberal to Labor over Green rose by 8.76 points in Melbourne, 4.27 points in Cooper and even 1.53 points in Wills (where it had been boosted in 2022 by donkey votes flowing from Liberal to Labor). Outside of Victoria the shifts were even larger, averaging 10.4 points across Canberra, Grayndler and Sydney. This shift was also seen in the Victorian Senate race, with a tendency for Liberal voters to move away from preferencing the Greens over Labor and instead to preference neither - this was especially strong in the federal seat of Melbourne where the share reaching the Greens dropped from 19.01 points to 11.59, but also strong in other inner city seats like Macnamara. At the same time Labor's share basically stayed the same, so it looks more like Liberal voters going off the Greens than becoming more pro-Labor.
If this flows through to the state election then the shift in Liberal preference flows could be greater. But given how much on the nose Victorian Labor are, perhaps it won't, or will only do so locally.
Labor Preferences
At the 2025 federal election there was a general weakening in Labor flows to the Greens in the Senate contest in Victoria (whether or not the votes were distributed, we can see where they all would have gone). See Prahran below for specific details re Macnamara but statewide in 2022 the flow of above the line ALP preferences was 68.83% to Greens, 18.78% to Coalition and 14.39% to exhaust (neither). In 2025 it was 64.44% to Greens, 21.19% to Coalition and 14.37% to exhaust. This represented a fall in continuing preferences from 78.6% to 75.3% and a drop in the Greens' gain rate from .501 preferences/vote to .433. We don't however know what those voters exhausting their vote would have done if they were forced to preference. There was a similar fall in Labor preference flows to Greens in the Queensland federal seat of Ryan, with the flow to Greens vs Coalition dropping from 83.52% to 77.32%. These falls may well have been partly because of normally 1 Coalition voters switching to 1 Labor, but it was also widely linked with Labor voters seeing the Greens as less palatable over Gaza, and with a degree of Labor supporter frustration at the tactics of Adam Bandt and Max Chandler-Mather. At the same time, Greens lower house preferences to Labor slightly strengthened.
Common Themes
There are a few themes I discuss several times below. Firstly an MP completing their first term will tend to get a boost compared to the state swings for or against their party based on them being a known rather than an unknown quantity in the community - this is often known as sophomore effect and is on average worth about a point. But this doesn't mean all such candidates will get this boost, since there is much more variation in swings from other factors.
Secondly there is a small benefit in being above a rival party on the ballot paper as one then receives the preferences of voters who have voted straight down the paper, known as donkey voting. However the donkey vote is generally 0.5% or less, and in most inner suburban seats it will be a lot less. Less researched, there appears to be a larger disadvantage (all else being equal) in drawing well down on a very long ballot paper, especially if rivals are near the top.
My article heavily uses these abbreviations:
2PP - two party preferred, the notional result between Labor and Liberal whether or not they were the final two candidates
2CP, 3CP, 4CP - n-candidate preferred. the notional or actual result between a number of parties. For most of this article I treat 3CP as effectively the main last-election result as it is the one that matters most for modelling this election; how many primary votes were 1 Greens as opposed to say 1 Victorian Socialists 2 Greens is generally not important in terms of the Greens' chances.
Target seats
Seats appear in alphabetical order.
ALBERT PARK
2022 2CP Labor vs Liberal 61.15.
2022 3CP Labor 39.45 Liberal 34.66 Greens 25.89
Incumbent: Nina Taylor (ALP), since 2022
With adverse Coalition card preferences, the Greens' only pathway in Albert Park is to knock Labor out. This requires Labor to lose 13.56 points at the 3CP stage relative to the Greens (a 6.78% 3CP swing) and it also requires the Coalition not to be third (but it's pretty clear they won't be). Albert Park was vacant in 2022 so Nina Taylor (ALP) should pick up a sophomore boost (generally worth about a point); donkey vote preferences have switched to favouring the Greens but I wouldn't think in this seat there would be many of those.
If Labor is knocked out that may not be the end of the story. If it happens because the swing against Labor goes fairly evenly between the others, then that's fine, but if it goes mostly to the Liberals then things get bumpy as the Liberal 3CP gets past, say, 43. The 3CP flow from Labor to Greens vs Liberals in Prahran was nearly 83% in 2022 but Sam Hibbins was a popular incumbent; it's possible here even with Labor recommending to the Greens that the flow could fall to 75% or so. That provides a backdoor way that the Liberals could win even if they can't get the 11.2% 2PP swing needed.
The Greens have been reported as running an open how to vote card here but it hasn't been registered yet; cards for surrounding seats have and they include an ordering for Albert Park. It will annoy Labor if they do run an open card but the impact of open Greens cards appears to be negligible, at least in inner city seats.
Oh and the Liberal candidate Andrew Cook is a property developer, but the Liberal website evasively says he's in "business". There is some interesting and not all that auspicious background on the Liberal preselection here. The Greens' candidate, Sonya Semmens, was also their candidate for Macnamara last year. This seat has a history of being hyped then fizzing.
BRUNSWICK
2022 2CP Green vs Labor 63.68
2022 3CP Green 55.15 Labor 31.89 Liberal 12.96
Incumbent: Vacant
Any commentary by me on this seat would not be complete without briefly paying tribute to the late Tim Read, who I knew mainly through his many and sterling contributions to getting rid of Group Ticket Voting.
After very narrowly gaining the seat for the Greens in 2018 Read got an enormous sophomore swing of 11.7% in 2022, with a few points of this being down to the change in the Liberals' preference strategy (but only a few as there are so few Liberal voters in this place). And not even all those few points will go back because the Liberals have issued an open how to vote card here, whatever that may do. I do expect the Greens could have some swing against here on account of the vacancy for a clearly popular former member (indeed the example of Balmain in NSW shows how there can be very big swings when a Greens incumbent is no longer there) but with Labor on the nose 13.7 points is a lot to find.
Brunswick has also been the focus of some pitiably wretched online campaigning by Labor, trying to scare what I'd hope is an informed and politically aware electorate off voting for the Greens with a completely baseless claim that the Greens taking seats (like, er, a seat the Greens already hold) off Labor could push Victoria closer to a Liberal-One Nation coalition. This is adapted from similar campaigns that Labor has used for a few years in some supposedly close elections where they could claim some remote pretext - there were independents who might potentially take which major party has the most seats into account in deciding who to back. But in this case none of it is even remotely true, and Labor so knows they are lying that the accompanying graphic shows a scenario where the right parties combined have way more of (votes? seats? coloured candy bars? who knows?) than the left. They're trying out this nonsense on how to vote cards in other Greens target seats too.
FOOTSCRAY
2022 2CP Labor vs Green 54.24
2022 3CP Labor 46.45 Green 32.48 Liberal 21.07
Incumbent: Katie Hall (ALP) since 2018
This seat at this election is completely bonkers. It was already looking like a messy exclusion order business where nobody would get any votes but now we have had further strange developments including a fifteen candidate field and even an open Liberal how to vote card.
In Footscray the 2022 results point to a Labor vs Greens 2CP though it's not unthinkable that the Liberals could displace one of those before losing anyway. The complications are that there will be a lot of exclusions before we get there, and this count is going to be slow and could well need to go to a full distribution to be sure there isn't some winner on preferences from well down. Victorian Socialists polled 9.3% here in 2022 and there's also a "community independent" Jess Marsh and former MLC Catherine Cumming in the mix, and the West Party, who seem to have a following in the local Vietnamese community. (Cumming was elected to Western Metropolitan as a Derryn Hinch Justice candidate in 2018 and immediately moved to the crossbench, leading to a vintage observer tweet I can no longer find that said something like "Welcome to Footscray Derryn. You got played." She's since been seen in the anti-COVID-mandate movement, attracted some heat for some extreme statements during it and sank without trace as an Angry Victorians candidate in 2022.) There are also candidates for all three of the Monica Smit/Avi Yemini group's fake name parties (which have caused Victorian Socialists to issue a warning on their how to vote card.) Oh and there's also One Nation.
There's every chance Footscray sets some kind of record for low leading primary votes in a single seat mainland election (I'm not sure what that record is but will anyone here even get 25%?). If when the dust settles it is Labor incumbent Katie Hall vs the Greens' Elena Pereyra, then the Liberals issuing an open how to vote card is likely to help Labor substantially less than had they preferenced Labor. On the other hand, a strengthening in flow to Labor beyond what is caused by the card - if that happens - could be worth a point or so. It might be that the baseline is really more like 56 or 57 to Labor in view of Liberal preferencing changes, but is that enough to hold off the impact on Labor of a big primary swing against?
MELBOURNE
2022 2CP Green vs Labor 60.19
2022 3CP Green 46.4 Labor 33.4 Liberal 20.17
Incumbent: Ellen Sandell (Greens) since 2014
The Greens lost the federal seat of Melbourne to Labor in the 2025 federal election, but it wasn't this end of the federal seat what done it. And that was a much better travelling Labor Party than this one. The Greens' margin here does in theory take a haircut from the Liberal card flowing to Labor (this could be worth 4-5%) and possibly from the Liberal preference flow to Labor strengthening. All the same 10.2% is a lot to close and with Labor travelling badly in general I don't see it happening, so I expect Sandell to retain Melbourne.
NORTHCOTE
2022 2CP ALP vs Greens 50.22
2022 3CP ALP 44.03 Greens 40.18 Liberal 15.79
Incumbent: Kat Theophanous (ALP) since 2018
Northcote is a cursed seat that the Greens won in a 2017 by-election, really should have held in 2018, and really really should have won back in 2022. However, the Kat may have nine lives as she has twice now managed to defeat them. In 2022 the Greens conceded this seat then it suddenly closed up in the postcount but they ended up just losing it anyway. On paper it's got to fall this time around except that the Liberals have flipped their preferences which is worth about 4%, and if Liberal flows to Labor also strengthen independently as in the federal election that might be another 1%. Oh and the ballot order benefit has switched from Greens to Labor (though the Greens being bottom of the 10 candidate field probably doesn't matter much with Labor being 8th). Surely all that's not enough and this time Labor's primary gets paddled so much off the statewide swing that it falls off that alone? Well one might think so, on the balance of probabilities, maybe ... we will see. After the last loss some insiders blamed the Greens' candidate selection for reasons I can no longer recall (the Australian did have a go at Campbell Gome for joining an Extinction Rebellion protest but I don't think that was it). Others claimed inadequate resourcing. Anyway the Vic Greens have a pattern of often persisting with the same candidates in a seat and Gome is back for a second attempt.
PASCOE VALE
2022 2CP ALP vs Greens 52.02
2022 3CP ALP 42.45 Greens 32.34 Liberal 25.22
Incumbent: Anthony Cianflone (ALP) since 2022
This seat was widely taken for granted in the leadup to 2022 but turned out to be rather close; I did a post then on the modelling issues caused by an independent running second in 2018. No independents in sight this time, just a bunch of Smit/Yemini fake name party candidates and the usual suspects. This is Anthony Cianflone's first defence so he should get a sophomore boost. He's also getting Liberal card preferences plus any benefit if the flow of other Liberal preferences strengthens, and so the Greens need several points back off other changes in vote share. They might get that; their Senate performance in this area was very strong in 2022, recording a 4CP vote over 38% so it is another growth area for them - but that probably mostly reflects the strength of the 2025 Wills campaign. However, this assumes this is a Labor vs Greens 2CP and it might not be; the 2022 Liberal 3CP is high enough that there is some chance the general state trends knock Labor out in third here handing the seat to the Greens, so there are two ways here the Greens can win. There is also a possibility that the Liberals are knocked out by One Nation at the 4CP stage, for what that matters. (I can't see either right party winning, they are just a complication in the exclusion process). Interesting.
For what it's worth (not much), Family First have recommended preferences direct to Cianflone citing his "Pro-life voting record". This resulted in Cianflone, who is an ALP Right "shoppie", posting a statement on Facebook saying "Women must be able to make their own decisions about their bodies and healthcare", supporting government policy in the area and claiming the Greens were unfairly taking advantage of the Family First endorsement.
PRAHRAN
2022 2CP Greens vs ALP 62.01
2022 3CP Greens 39.14 Liberal 33.27 Labor 27.59
2022 2PP Labor vs Liberal 61.07
2025 By-Election 2CP Lib vs Green 51.35 (Labor did not contest)
Incumbent: Rachel Westaway (Lib) since 2025
The Greens are on a 12% margin here so they are prohibitive favourites, right? Not so fast. Firstly Prahran is what I call a disrupted seat - it changed hands during the term at a by-election. In 2PP contests, disrupted seats normally behave somewhere between their last-election baseline and the by-election result. However Prahran is a unique case because had Labor run in 2025 and made the same preference recommendation as in 2022, the Greens would have retained the seat and hence it wouldn't be disrupted. The 2026 contest sees Labor (who everyone expects to be out in third) running this time, but with an open how to vote card, and the challenge here is working out what that does.
There's no precedent for Labor doing this in a Liberal-Green contest where they were excluded. The best I can do is look at Senate data, where in the overlapping seat of Macnamara, Labor left the Greens off their Senate how to vote in 2025. This was as a result of sensitivities within the local Jewish community based on the Greens' position on Gaza. The impact was significant. In 2022 Labor above the line Senate preferences went 81.23-11.73 to the Greens with 6.99% exhaust, a 87.4% flow of decided preferences (7.1 points above the state total) with a near 0.7 preferences per vote gain rate. This was among the strongest flows in the country with the lowest exhaust in the state. In 2025 however Labor preferences went only 54.77-18.37 to the Greens with 26.86% exhaust, a 74.9% flow rate of decided preferences (0.4 points below the state total) with the gain rate nearly cut in half and the highest exhaust rate in the state. We don't know what those voters who chose to exhaust their vote here would have done if they had to make a choice, but if they flowed the same way as those who did make a choice then that would mean a 12.5% drop in flow, compared to a 5% drop for the state overall. It could potentially be more than that.
In 2022 Sam Hibbins had an 83% flow rate from Labor's 3CP exclusion, but he was an incumbent and Westaway is now the incumbent. The 3CP flow this time might plausibly be as low as, say, the mid 60s. If it is that low then a flip from the 2022 6% Greens to Liberal 3CP lead to a Liberal over Greens lead of the same size starts to make things interesting if the Labor vote is smashed. The ballot order is good for the Liberals in that Westaway is high on a large ballot and picks up donkey preferences (shouldn't be many of those here) but on the other hand Labor and the Greens are next to each other which may help a bit with preference flow.
There's a colourful undercast here including Sack Dan Andrews founder Tosh Jake-Finnigan, Morgan Jonas of "Safety Victoria - Violent Crime Prevention" (nee Freedom Party, their only run at this election), a couple of Smit/Yemini fake name parties, and independent Max Dicks whose name draws online attention.
PRESTON
2022 2CP Labor vs Greens 52.09
2022 3CP Labor 44.21 Greens 31.72 Liberal 24.07
Incumbent: Nathan Lambert (ALP) since 2022
Preston is rather similar to Pascoe Vale in considerations for this count. The 2022 count for this seat was complicated by the late independent Gaetano Greco, who for a while looked like he could win the seat from fourth but in the end didn't quite get out of there and would not have been that close anyway. It finished up as Labor vs Greens with Labor retaining, just, in the face of an insane 19.2% 2CP swing. Preston has the added entertainments in 2026 of former Ringwood Labor MP Will Fowles running (nobody knows why here) as an independent, and the One Nation candidate being disendorsed (with his name on the ballot paper) after among other things tweeting that Hitler was the GOAT. (So much for One Nation's supposed new vetting prowess; the comments were on a real-name twitter account that was open to anyone to see.) It has also collected the full set of three Yemini/Smit fake name parties.
One Nation has still listed their disendorsed candidate as a recommended 1 vote on their statewide how to vote card although a very similar Liberal card that recommended a 1 for a disendorsed candidate in Yan Yean 2018 was determined to be illegal. There may be some difference in that One Nation may not have told the VEC the candidate was disendorsed, but it is at least possible that One Nation's statewide card should be deregistered as it misleads electors in relation to the casting of their votes. Anyway three days after disendorsing their candidate One Nation still registered official material asking voters to vote for them.
Incumbent Nathan Lambert has a scungy ballot draw, last out of 11 with whatever donkey vote there is flowing to the Liberals at 3 and the Greens at 6. However he also had a bad draw in 2022. As with Pascoe Vale he can expect a boost from the switch in Liberal card preferences and as with Pascoe Vale he might also get the benefit of any general trend among Liberal voters who choose for themselves. And he is also a first-term defending MP. However his starting 3CP is a bit higher than Cianflone's and so it's a bit harder to knock him out of the top three.
Preston has not greened up at federal level to the same extent as Pascoe Vale with the 2025 Senate 4CP six points lower, however this probably partly reflects Labor having such a lock on Cooper that the Greens don't run as hard there as in Wills. A major factor in the 2022 result was concern about proposed development of Preston Market, and while the future shape of the market is still a matter of debate on the campaign trail, I suspect the focus on it now is less. A further point of interest here is that Lambert, who defeated Robin Scott for preselection after Scott ran into IBAC trouble, is really strongly disliked by some online Greens supporters and independent lefties, who claim he isn't progressive enough for the seat. They consider him not just an everyday Shoppie (and his was backed by the Right and SDA) but an especially irksome example of the faction.
There's also an indie we should keep half an eye on - Zheng Chin, an urban planner, is endorsed by the Darebin Progressive Independents Network, a group founded by Greco which runs in local elections.
For what it's worth (again not much), Family First have recommended preferences in effect to Lambert at 3, this time without explanation.
RICHMOND
2022 2CP Greens vs ALP 57.32
2022 3CP Greens 42.96 Labor 35.98 Liberal 21.06
Incumbent: Gabrielle de Vietri (Greens) since 2022
One would think this isn't really on the table. If Labor are having a rotten election and changes in Liberal preference flows aren't worth 7.3 points by themselves then it wouldn't seem that they can win this, at the best make it close - especially with the Greens having a first term incumbent. But Labor actually seem to be giving Richmond a go (to cries of how dare they from some Greens supporters online) and the reason is what happened in Melbourne in the federal election. Fuelled by hardening conservative preferences, dissatisfaction with the Greens' performance in the 2020-4 Yarra City Council term and the added bonus of having a candidate local to Richmond, Labor ran up booth swings in the high single and low double figures in the Richmond part of the seat leading to their upset win over Adam Bandt. This was without the benefit of a Liberal preference shift either. How transferrable is it? Probably not very, but this plus the slightly closer margin than Melbourne and Brunswick means the seat is seen as more loseable than those.
Near-target seats
2022 2CP Labor vs Liberal 65.45
2022 3CP Labor 51.93 Liberal 29.95 Greens 18.12
Incumbent: Kathleen Matthews-Ward (ALP) since 2022
This is an odd one. With Labor on 52% 3CP to the Greens on 18 in 2022 and with Labor with a defending first-term incumbent, what's this seat doing here? Well actually, there is at least one reason why this seat's been popping up in some model talk, and that is that the federal results here were radically different to the state election. Alex Jago's model gives the Senate 3CP here as Labor 43.87 Greens 30.06 Coalition 26.08. When you then apply an expected swing on top of this based on state polling, Labor very nearly gets excluded.
How is this so? Well, the southern part of Broadmeadows is in Wills which saw a massive Greens campaign and the whole seat has the state's highest Muslim population (the rest of it is in Calwell). This is one of the places where MVM campaigning kicked in bigtime with Gaza-related issues and other discontents driving preferences to the Greens and Reps booth swings in cases as high as 27%. There are probably some demographic spreading-out factors in this as well. MVM have had no attention whatsoever this campaign but they will apparently be launching how to vote guides on November 18, though I don't know if their cards will be registered for handout or what the scale of their booth campaign might be if so.
Overall mapping federal elections to state elections has a long history of seldom working (except for Victoria 2022 where some federal-based models did extremely well) and saying that the MVM factor will be even nearly as big as in the federal election would be a reckless call. However Muslim voter views are another thing that could drive a whacking of the Labor primary here down towards Calwell territory alongside the general swing and outer suburban issues. The bookies have One Nation second favourite here but that that doesn't seem especially informed.
On a 2PP basis, 15.5% in an outer suburb seat might not be entirely safe in this election, but that's coming off a vacancy so Matthews-Ward should get a sophomore advantage. (In 2018 Labor won the 2PP in this seat 80-20!) At the moment I think the sort of things that have been highlighted with this seat more point to the potential for it to be a messy preference distribution, rather than one where the Greens have a serious chance. Labor polled 45.7% primary in 2022; this can be knocked down into say the low 30s without anyone necessarily beating them.
ESSENDON
2022 2CP Labor vs Liberal 62.45
2022 3CP Labor 43.78 Liberal 33.23 Greens 22.99
Incumbent: Vacant
This one is mainly getting discussed because with the retirement of 12-year incumbent and Minister Danny Pearson, a 12.45% margin vs the Liberals may or may not hold but is not safe, and is the sort of seat where Labor has the sandbags out. There's some thought the Labor vote could collapse to such a point here that the Greens make the top two but in terms of winning it has the same problem as Monbulk below - if that happens the Liberals are over 45 on 3CP and home against any opponent. This one also has the complication of Oscar Yildiz running as an indie. Essendon is another seat where the Greens are reportedly running an open card but have included a ranked order for it in surrounding seats.
IVANHOE
2022 2CP Labor vs Liberal 62.75
2022 3CP Labor 44.17 Liberal 34.03 Greens 20.96
Incumbent: Anthony Carbines (ALP) since 2010
This one has popped up as around a 10% chance on AEF at times and did have a very high Greens primary (19.2%) in 2022, but the latter was mainly because of having a small field. They're also at $15 in the betting, which is a lot shorter than many other seats, but $15 candidates only actually win about 1% of the time (it's called longshot bias). Unless Labor support completely collapses I just can't get the Greens into the 2CP in this seat. And if it does, same thing as Essendon and Monbulk; the Liberals will then have too much.
MONBULK
2022 2CP ALP vs Liberal 57.55
2022 3CP Labor 39.66 Liberal 37.45 Greens 22.9
Incumbent: Daniela Di Martino (ALP) since 2022
This one has also made the odd appearance in model talk but I think the problem with it is pretty obvious. 16.76 points of 3CP (8.38% swing) isn't a vast gap between Labor and the Greens, so maybe one wouldn't rule out Labor falling to third after preferences. But if they did then it would be because the swing to the Liberals put the Liberals on well over 45 meaning that the Liberals would defeat the Greens on 2CP. This is also yet another Labor sophomore seat making it a little bit harder to shift.



